xdtalk.com is your place to go. I never even tried to put my xd9 service in that holster and don't really plan on it. I can't carry anyways (until I move), although I may use it for this Utah non-resident CCW class that's coming up (recommended, not necessary), so maybe I'll give it a try (I just cleaned and put it away so I'll try tomorrow haha). The consensus on xdtalk is that the crossbreed supertuck is their favorite although there are many others discussed over there. fivehourfrenzy just ordered a couple of other brand holsters for his xd9sc although he doesn't have them yet to give you a review. Go over to xdtalk and I'm sure you'll find the answers you're looking for.