I guess that would be what you like the the best as for eye appeal. I have a 1911r carry in stainless.
It runs very well although because of it's width. there's not much choices for holsters. The rail has a
tendency to gouge as you put it into your holster,but the light rail is a nice feature.Having a light at the ready on the gun, there's no fumbling with a flashlight with your weak hand. Being that it's
stainless I don't worry about moisture that much. Sig's elite line nice looking,they did hit a homerun as far as looks. The only down side is the price, most 1911 manufacturers are out of touch with reality, but we still keep buying these over priced clunkers.

accuracy the same on both?