Lots of good opinions here. Robert
Printable View
Lots of good opinions here. Robert
Like I said, there could be several reasons that it was so lop-sided at this particular vendor. I'd be interested to know how the 2 are selling compared to eachother. Glock had a great design, but some people see that it's been improved upon. And for the rest... its Glock or nothing!Quote:
Originally Posted by nailer
I would put my XD against any Glock- round for round!
i've shot all 3, and i lke all 3 but i voted for the M&P
Personally I like the 24/7 OSS. Until you shoot one, don't criticize one. As far as glock being the only proven design, Ha! When the military opened up bids for a new service pistol (JCP or Joint Combat Pistol) several manufacturers submited pistols that can pass any torture test thrown at it. They're all good guns
I don't care for Glocks. They don't fit my hand well.
The XD's I've shot were good.
The M&P's are the ones I spent my money on.
i went with the M&P here for 1 main reason. I have always had an issue with the way the Glock feels to me. IMO, the Glock is a brick with a handle on it. Like the poster said here, I have never been very accurate with a Glock, although obviously many people are. It all comes down to personal preference in this poll. I have shot all 3 of these models and I thought the M&P just felt better to me.
A gun has to have a visual appeal to me for to buy it. The XD to me is butt ugly. The Glock, I have two, is like holding a 2 X 4 unfortunately, so that leaves the S&W. I have a S&W M&P .45 Compact and I like it. Maybe not as well as my Wilson nor my Fuzion but I have to cop to liking the good old 1911 best.
If it don't start with a 4 and end with a 5 it just ain't worth havin.
I have tried a Glock 23 and didn't like it. Never tried the XD. I have, however, used and liked the M&P. I now have a M&Pc in .40. I'm very impressed with it. I think it compares favorably with my HK USPc in .40. I haven't had it long enough to now about durability, but I see no reasons to be concered in that area.
I've had my M&P .40fs since 06 and it's been nothing but a pleasure to own.
I've always been a Glock man, but to be fair and unbiased, I shot a XD compact 9 that I rented the other day. I was impressed, but not converted. While my shot group was better, I had a hard time sighting. I missed the familiar white "U" of the Glock rear sights. The trigger pull on my G19 felt more natural. The XD felt really top heavy. All things considered, I do see me owning a XD in the future, but not to replace my Glocks.
M&P
XD for me.
Barry
Never shot the M&P, but I own a Glock 19 and a XD45. I like both guns, and can shoot both well. The I like the trigger a little better on my XD, but the trigger reset is much better on my Glock.
Both serve me well for what I bought them for.
Yeah, all are good! I'd say XD. But I own a Glock too.:smt023
I've never shot a M&p, but I don't like the feel of the Glock or XD.
Shoot a MP and you will be hooked. Great ergonomics (IMHO), very accurate and very dependable with a great, no BS warranty just in case you need it. I have three MP's and love all of them!Quote:
Originally Posted by thelonerang3r
A friend of mine recently bought a NIB Glock 17 which usually is a very dependable gun. It has had repeated feed problems. She callled Glock, they said to send it to them and they would either repair it or give her a new one. The bad news is, she has to pay shipping expenses both ways. That sucks!!
Glock,m&p,xd.........! I would chose ruger SR9!!! I own m&p 9mm with crimson laser grips and the xdm 9mm,xd40 sub compact with nitesites,xd 45 with lasermax.I dont own a glock but have shot many. Also a very nice pistol. But i must say when i got my sr9 ruger my other guns are collecting dust! This sr9 is my favorite
I've shot em all and I hate em all... maybe it's just me though.
i voted for the xd/xdm, they feel amazing, close second is m&p, and not to take anything away from glock, they are great too, they go bang everytime,
Safer ?? I suppose you have not tried a H&K