Yes, I'm new so bear with me.
I'd like to read pros and cons about using graphite for a gun lubricant
It's slick and dry.
It won't gum up with burnt powder.
It won't evaporate or thin out with heat.
It won't drain or migrate.
It won't wear out.
A five-cent pencil should last a lifetime.
It won't cushion a blow.
It won't penetrate.
Will it preserve?
Where should it be used?
Where should it not be used?
Talk to me.
I would suggest these alternatives that are made specifically for weapon lubrication.
Militec – 1
Steel Shield's Weapon's Shield
graphite - great for pine-wood derby.
Firearms.... I don't think it does well with heat and burning stuff.
It seems to me I'm cleaning graphite off my guns [burnt powder] and particle fouling is not a good thing.
Am I right that to get good lubrication, you need a thicker amount of graphite? That will cause problems on higher tolerance firearms.
Besides, I don't see the graphite motor oils anymore, maybe because its difficult to tell dirt from that kind of lubricant.
Graphite is a very good lubricant.
But, it readily falls off. It doesn't remain in place.
That's why it was commonly mixed with oil or grease, "back in the day."
Also, back then, it was found that Molybdenum disulfide, also in grease, worked better than did graphite.
Don't use a pencil "lead." That isn't pure graphite.
Pencil "lead" contains quite a lot of powdered clay, which is an abrasive.
Modern lubricants tend to use Teflon, instead of graphite.
Some of those formulŠ work pretty well indeed.
In my mind, guns need pretty constant attention. I therefore suggest that you won't do well, using a "permanent" lubricant.
I use only simple oil, except on my Garand (which needs Moly grease). I recommend Ballistol, but anything, including old-fashion 3-in-1, will do the job.
Break-Free is all you need.
Ballistol, Hoppes #9 and Tetra grease work fine on all my firearms.
US made Ruger, Springfield, Remington: ..... Frog lube
Euro Beretta, SigSauer, CZ: ..... Hoppes gun oil
Hoppes #9 for cleaning, and CLP/RemOil for lube. Seriously, there are a ton of decent cleaning/lube products out there that do a good job, but don't use graphite on your weapon.
I have been happy with shooters choice products, solvent and oil. There are many great products dedicated to clean lube your gun. I wouldn't use graphite.
There are plenty of good options these day's including using synthetic motor oil....
The only plus I've read about is graphite will not congeal at arctic temperatures.
Since I don't plan to every be that cold, Miltec or Hops is good enough for me.
I never understand why people want to use NON gun products on guns. I think they people who design/engineer gun lubes really know what they're doing and what a gun's lubrication requirements are better than a car guy does.
That being said, I don't think there's much difference between Outers, vs. CLP vs. any body else's oil. Can somebody come forward and tell us about a pistol that was just seized up because the oil failed? I think not.
Froglube is another story. I use it in most cases where it makes sense. But for the average home shooter I think 3-in-1 oil is just fine. Save your money and buy a better grade of ammo.