That's some list. I can only say I've dealt with a few. Here's how I rate them:
Personal Defense and Handgun:
There is one that is not on the list that I just "discovered".
Fuquay Guns & Gold
513 Wake Chapel Road
Fuquay Varina, NC 27526
Haven't been in but decided to give them the shot as my FFL for my SIG that's coming in. They're five minutes away from my house and only $25 for the transfer fee. I'll have more of an opinion once the transaction is completed, but so far so good.
UPDATE: Fuquay Guns and Gold
Decent selection of guns, OK prices, but ammo killed them. I wanted some Gold Dots and the guy tied to push some Federal +P+ ammo on me saying it "Was the best defense ammo available". Well, I hate it when people say something is "the best". I told him I'd stick to the Gold Dots, that they didn't have, and picked them up at another shop.