Looking for BEST - 9mm - for home protection?!? - Page 2

    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
    Results 21 to 40 of 41
    1. #21
      Member plentyofpaws's Avatar
      Join Date
      Nov 2008
      Location
      Little Rock, Arkansas
      Posts
      412
      A couple of other suggestions, the Sig 2022 as mentioned, is an excellent piece; Taurus Millenium Pro and EAA (European American Armory) make affordable reliable guns as well.

      Only caution about buying at a gun show, be sure the dealer you are dealing is reputable. I've heard stories about the gun looking pristine, but ending up to be a piece of crap.

    2. #22
      Member SigZagger's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2006
      Location
      Ohio
      Posts
      472
      Regarding two you mentioned, the Walther P99 and a SigSauer P228 or 229. I own the P99 and P229. I'm guessing the grip on a Sig may be too thick for your girlfriend...maybe. I purchased a LEO trade-in Sig P229, 9mm for $500.00. The Walther P99 was NIB for $550.00 (probably lower than CA prices). It can be complicated (at first) to operate an AS model for a new shooter. However, the QA model is the same DAO trigger pull every time. Plus, the grip comes with three different grip attachments for a better feel/grip. Check your local gun shops for LEO trade-ins, it can save you money, and you'll know that gun is functional and reliable. Not many rounds down the pipe, except for qualification shooting. Just remember to choose the correct model handgun for you. If you don't, and you try to sell it afterwards, it's like a car driven off the showroom floor, you loose money quickly.

    3. #23
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Oct 2009
      Posts
      16
      Quote Originally Posted by SigZagger View Post
      Regarding two you mentioned, the Walther P99 and a SigSauer P228 or 229. I own the P99 and P229. I'm guessing the grip on a Sig may be too thick for your girlfriend...maybe. I purchased a LEO trade-in Sig P229, 9mm for $500.00. The Walther P99 was NIB for $550.00 (probably lower than CA prices). It can be complicated (at first) to operate an AS model for a new shooter. However, the QA model is the same DAO trigger pull every time. Plus, the grip comes with three different grip attachments for a better feel/grip. Check your local gun shops for LEO trade-ins, it can save you money, and you'll know that gun is functional and reliable. Not many rounds down the pipe, except for qualification shooting. Just remember to choose the correct model handgun for you. If you don't, and you try to sell it afterwards, it's like a car driven off the showroom floor, you loose money quickly.

      Thanks so far guys, I have to ask, sigzagger, what is an LEO trade-in? is it different than a normal trade-in? Got it, I've always bought used (except for a FEW things in my life) I thought after the army (and being around really used and abused guns) that I didn't want to take a chance with something like this, BUT if I may be able to purchase something I like at a reasonable price...I think I'll be swayed.

      I'm going to head down to a place called old west gun room (in richmond, ca - I believe) today, I've heard the guy there has a nice selection of pistols... maybe he'll have a few trade-ins...

    4. #24
      Member
      Join Date
      Apr 2007
      Posts
      982
      Quote Originally Posted by as-of-now View Post
      Also, I was going to ask - what do you all think of buying a used (but still in good condition) gun?

      Lastly, are there fees the registered gun dealers charge to us lesser lucky people to receive the gun?
      I have purchased numerous used guns over the years. A few were off of gunbroker.com, and were in worse condition that stated, but that's the risk you take. Obviously I have no problem with used guns, and I have also come across some excellent bargains as well, such as a nearly-new Sig 239 for a hair over $400.

      An FFL dealer will charge a certain amount to do a transfer of a used firearm over to you. How much varies a lot, and seems to be higher in CA. I'm in TX, and my FFL charges me $10, but then again I am a very good customer. Of course if you buy a new handgun, the fees are essentially built into the selling price of the firearm.

    5. #25
      Member HGF Gold Member dosborn's Avatar
      Join Date
      Apr 2009
      Location
      Springfield, MO
      Posts
      882
      I think Bud's had CPO Sig P250's for $399. I know someone did a week ago.

      I like my P250 (.45). The trigger takes some getting used too but that's a cheap fix with snap caps. You could get the 9mm and then step up to the .40 or .357 sig conversion kit for the 250, WHEN they are released.

    6. #26
      Junior Member Tucker's Avatar
      Join Date
      Sep 2009
      Location
      Somewhere out here and there...
      Posts
      92
      Compacts are good. I have a Glock 23 with interchangeable barrels for the 9 x 19 mm and for the .357 caliber. Easy drop in. Love the way it fits my small hand. I also have a Bersa Thunder .380 but it has a bugger of gun for a trigger. I passed my CCW with the Bersa though...the smaller the barrel, the more recoil so I heard.

    7. #27
      Senior Member
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      Kentucky
      Posts
      3,373
      Heh..Buds usually always has them. It's a great benefit to be able to go into the shop and see what's wandered in.

    8. #28
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Oct 2009
      Posts
      16
      Yesterday I checked out a Ruger (which i didn't like the feel of). Also, a Beretta 92, (a bit on the large side, bit I liked it). There a 1911, which I don't think I'd like right now, slightly heavy (not poly) and maybe not the best for the girlfriend, either. Lastly, there was a beretta px4. I loved this gun. It has a good feel in your hand - substantial, The grip is a bit on the wider side, the slide isn't too hard to pull back (for the misses), and it's a sa/da gun. I HATED the slide mount safety (I don't know why they do it...) But I suppose it's something I can get used to.

      After being in the shop, checking out so many beautiful expensive pistols (they had an HK USP, and an FN 57) I realized that for what I need this gun for, I'm setting my pricepoint too high. Money is an issue for me, and I can get a great weapon for in the 500 dollar range. I don't know if that changes the suggestions put forth in this thread so far, but I suppose the PX4 and the baby Eagle are two guns in the running, but I'm open to all else.

      Thanks for the suggestions so far, everyone!

    9. #29
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Oct 2009
      Posts
      16
      Oh lastly, I didn't love the feel of the glock in my hand. I'm not going to discredit it until I shoot though.

    10. #30
      Member SigZagger's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2006
      Location
      Ohio
      Posts
      472
      Quote Originally Posted by as-of-now View Post
      I have to ask, sigzagger, what is an LEO trade-in? is it different than a normal trade-in?
      A LEO (law enforcement officer) trade-in is a weapon that was owned and issued to active duty officers by some LE agency. That means they are damn near 100% reliable and shot very few times. Officers are required to meet qualification standards from 1-4 times a year. Normally 50-60 rounds a trip. Add it up on the age of the gun and compared to civilian use it will be a low round count. Many can't get passed the scratches, dust and sometimes grime of these guns. A good cleaning and polishing does wonders. So, in a nut shell, they normally cost less than a new shiny model. Unfortunately, many gun stores do not carry such trade-ins. Just keep it in the back of your mind during your visits to one store after another.

    11. #31
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Oct 2009
      Posts
      16
      Hey everyone, yesterday I tested a springfield, SandW version of the p99, and a glock. I love the looks and feel of the p99, it is the most balanced and good feeling gun yet. And, I don't mind the AS trigger, AFTER the first shot. The first shot however is a long unpredictable stroke, however it may be fine with some getting used to. (in short, a complete turn off.) For me, he springfield was good in all areas, just not GREAT. And the glock, while I don't like the feel of it in my hand, I really liked the feel of the trigger and the way it shot. Next time it'll be a sig, M and P, and maybe the beretta storm if I can find one to shoot.

      The latter is probably the best feeing in my hand.

      Thanks for all the input and help so far, everyone.

    12. #32
      Administrator
      VAMarine's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 2008
      Location
      Iowa
      Posts
      3,860
      Quote Originally Posted by as-of-now View Post
      Hey everyone, yesterday I tested a springfield, SandW version of the p99, and a glock. I love the looks and feel of the p99, it is the most balanced and good feeling gun yet. And, I don't mind the AS trigger, AFTER the first shot. The first shot however is a long unpredictable stroke, however it may be fine with some getting used to. (in short, a complete turn off.) For me, he springfield was good in all areas, just not GREAT. And the glock, while I don't like the feel of it in my hand, I really liked the feel of the trigger and the way it shot. Next time it'll be a sig, M and P, and maybe the beretta storm if I can find one to shoot.

      The latter is probably the best feeing in my hand.

      Thanks for all the input and help so far, everyone.

      Sounds like you're doing it right, if you practice more the DA trigger pull isn't that bad...I hate them, but I never took the time to get overly proficient with a DA trigger pull on an auto.

    13. #33
      PX
      PX is offline
      Member
      Join Date
      May 2006
      Location
      SE GA.
      Posts
      101
      [QUOTE=as-of-now;

      That said, I have to love the look of the gun, which is why I'm straying from the glock. I've been looking at a few guns in particular. First off, I love the Jericho (baby eagle) polymer compact. Also, the Walther p99 is a great looking gun (never held it though). And I've heard great things about the SIG's - I was thinking maybe a p229 or 239 (don't really know the difference) or a p250 (which I've heard mixed things about).
      I would appreciate any info on the handguns I just mentioned - reviews, comparisons, opinions on which are best, etc.
      Also, if there are other guns that I didn't mention that you think might fit the bill, let me know.
      Thanks in advance for your time an patience in dealing with a handgun newb....[/QUOTE]


      JMOO:

      I had a P239, excellent pistol. I had a Walther P99c/AS, excellent pistol, amazingly accurate. I had a couple of Glocks, and while there are a zillion folks carrying them I just could never warm up to them.

      I held the Jericho, but it was a bit too "hefty" for my taste in a carry weapon.

      Here's a suggestion that you might not have an interest in, but folks who have them love 'em, and if your female counterpart is going to be shooting whatever gun you buy I think she will love it.

      S&W 3913LS.... Third generation Smiths have a reputation for absolute reliability (as much as a pistol can be), and are more than self defense accurate. The LadySmith in particular seems to be a favorite of many people, and consequently are kinda pricey for a 3rd gen Smith, but you should be able to find one, NIB within your price range. The LadySmith will come with a lifetime warranty.

      Just another choice.

      Best Wishes,

      Jesse

    14. #34
      Member twodogs's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      SW PA
      Posts
      148
      FWIW - Take a look at the Stoeger Cougar. For about 400 bucks you will have a gun that is as accurate & reliable as one could hope for at twice the price. The only downside is the weight since it is not a polymer. If you spend a little time researching that gun you will find that it is the old Beretta Cougar, made with the same tooling as the old Beretta. Parts are interchangable, and having fired both, I couldn't tell the difference. I own a Stoeger Cougar, and I have no regrets with the purchase.

    15. #35
      Member Dynamik1's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 2007
      Location
      Pittsboro, NC
      Posts
      281
      Just outta curiousity - you mentioned being newly out of the service - why isnt the M9 or Beretta 92FS on your list? Its about $500 and reliable as all get out. Plus, being made for armed forces, the grip is middle of the road in thickness.

    16. #36
      Senior Member hideit's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 2007
      Location
      west chester ohio
      Posts
      1,499
      you said for your wife...
      9mm
      exposed hammer so that you can cock it and it is easier to rack the slide to chamber a round
      single stack would be better for her hand - walther and
      FN P9 but it is double stack but might fit
      have you thought of the .380's?

    17. #37
      Banned
      Join Date
      Dec 2009
      Posts
      15

      looks

      just my 2 cents but you wouldnt buy a fugly car j because it fit your need some do i know but looks is something to consider not as important as function / reliability but still a factor

    18. #38
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Mar 2012
      Posts
      40
      For $400 maybe less you can get a Stoeger Cougar 9mm and it will protect the heck out of you. This one well made pistol, I have one. Little recoil, shoots very well, accurate, just one heck of a gun. Have NEVER had a problem with it with 700 rounds thru it. When I first got it I cleaned it then oiled it well wit Rem Oil and I keep it that way after every range practice. You can not go wrong with a Stoeger Cougar.

    19. #39
      JJW
      JJW is offline
      Junior Member JJW's Avatar
      Join Date
      Feb 2012
      Location
      Dayton, Oh area
      Posts
      3
      If she has problems with the slides of the various mentioned guns, don't discount the .380 cal. It's about as small a caliber as I would go, but with the increased popularity of the .380, the ammo manufacturers are making some very impressive rounds for personnel protection. I have a Bersa Thunder.380 that I carry with Hornady FXT ammo and feel just as protected as when I carry my 9mm. As I'm sure you are aware, it's not necessarily the caliber, but the placement of the shot, that counts most. My sister-in-law has trouble with slides being too hard to safely operate and she Carries a snub nose S&W revolver. Just keep pulling the trigger until it quits going bang and only goes click.

    20. #40
      Member
      Join Date
      Jan 2011
      Location
      Richmond, VA
      Posts
      261
      I haven't read a lot of the posts... so I apologize if this is entire irrelevant...

      The best advice, as already stated, is to go to a range and decide for yourself which is best. There are many reliable and well made guns that meet your criteria. You need to find the one that fits best in your hand and that you feel the most comfortable shooting.

      That said...here are my specific responses....

      You really cannot beat a Glock 19. I would reconsider you're cosmetic indifference toward Glock.

      I don't have experience with polymer guns other than Glock. I assume your polymer preference has more to do with weight than the material itself. If that's true, then I recommend the CZ P-01. It is a highly regarded compact 9mm with a light alloy frame. So you get the weight benefit.

      Good luck!

    Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast

    Sponsored Links

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •  

    Search tags for this page

    9mm for personal protection
    ,
    9mm handgun for protection
    ,
    9mm home protection
    ,
    best 9mm ammo for personal protection
    ,

    best 9mm for home defense

    ,
    best 9mm for home protection
    ,
    best 9mm for personal protection
    ,
    best 9mm for protection
    ,
    best 9mm handgun for home protection
    ,
    best 9mm handguns for home protection
    ,

    best 9mm home defense

    ,
    names of 9mm home protection guns
    Click on a term to search for related topics.

    Tags for this Thread