Results 1 to 3 of 3
  1. #1
    wp is offline
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2012

    Advantage Arms 22 conversion VS Kimber 22 conversion

    Hi All,
    I'm new to the forum so I apologize if this topic has been beat to death (I'm too lazy to search past topics).
    I know the Kimber 22 conversion kit is pretty good from the reviews I've read but it doesn't have the steel insert to hold the slide open after the last shot. I'm looking for this feature but don't know how well it works in different 1911 models. I've looked at 3 conversion kits:
    Kimber...seems to be with some experimentation a good solid 22 but no hold open last shot. Cost approx. $325.00.

    Advantage Arms: has hold open feature, costs approx $275.00 Have no idea of quality or accuracy.

    Marvel 22 conversion: has hold open feature, very accurate and functions well. Cost about $400.00

    I have ruled out the Marvel. Can any one comment about the advantage Arms VS Kimber.

  2. #2
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    I can tell you that the Kimber .22 conversion that I bought, used, for a Colt Gold Cup shoots straighter than the road to hell, and has been entirely reliable with good ammunition (CCI's) and even works well with Federal bulk pack stuff for autos.
    The package also shoots extraordinarily straight.
    There is apparently some challenge in getting the slide stop to engage with magazine actuation, so it doesn't work that way on the Kimber. However, a 'dry snap' on an empty chamber is supposed to hurt nothing whatsoever.
    If my experience is any guide, get the Kimber and have done with it.

  3. #3
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    I had the same questions and after shooting a friends Kimber Conversion I decided to go with Kimber. After having my 22 conversion for 6 months I can say I love it. I put my Kimber Gold Match in my machine rest with the conversion and tested several brands of 22 ammo. So far the CCI Mini Mag gave me the best 1-1/8 " ten round groups at 25 yards. That's plenty good enough for me. Additionally, the Kimber is not picky about ammo as long as it is high velocity. Standard velocity does not have enough power to cycle the slide. When you get the conversion I would suggest hosing down the barrel/slide assembly with Kroil Penetrating Oil before installing it, then work the slide sever hundred times. Keep spraying down the barrel/slide assembly to wash out any residue then take it to the range. The Kroil will give plenty of luberciation and speeds the break in process, it also works great for general shooting luberication.

    I have heard that the Advantage conversoin has lots of feeding issues, but I cannot confirm this personally. I also understand the Marvel Conversion will only work with one or two typs of ammo.

Remove Ads

Sponsored Links

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Search tags for this page

advantage arms 1911 conversion
advantage arms 1911 conversion kit
advantage arms 1911 conversion kit reviews
advantage arms 1911 conversion kit vs kimber
advantage arms 1911 conversion review
advantage arms 1911-22t
advantage arms vs kimber
advantage arms vs kimber .22 conversion

kimber 22 conversion

kimber vs marvel 22 conversion
tactical solutions versus kimber 1911 .22 conversion review
will advantagearms conversion kit for a kimber
Click on a term to search for related topics.