I have Fobus Paddle holsters for my S&W Sigma and my 1911. They fit great and totally secure the gun. I've never had an incident of the gun or holster coming loose in any way no matter what I'm doing. The contour of the paddle fits my 4 O'Clock carry position very well. I don't even need a T-Shirt between my skin and the paddle. For my XD, I bought an XD Paddle Holster and it doesn't compare to the Fobus. The XD's belt clip protrusion is way too big and it is very hard to take off. The Fobus is much more friendly. After a long day of carry, the last thing you want to do is wrestle to get your holster off. It also doesn't hurt that they are one of the lowest priced holsters on the market.