Decisions, decisions, decisions, .40 or .45, Sig, Springfield, or Glock?

    Results 1 to 14 of 14
    1. #1
      Banned
      Join Date
      Nov 2012
      Posts
      521

      Decisions, decisions, decisions, .40 or .45, Sig, Springfield, or Glock?

      Alright guys, I've asked a few questions regarding this before but I think I'm finally ready to buy another hand gun!?!

      I purchased my Beretta px4 storm (full size 9mm) and love it a few months ago but I would like to broaden my collection.

      I'm somewhat on a budget but if its worth the extra few hundred bucks to save, maybe I'll get Sig? I've also been taken back by the Springfield Xdm select. I'm leaving towards a .40 cal due to the price and availability of ammo. I was a fan of Glock but the safety interlocks I've stated before? I dunno.

      Other thing is, I have a full size Beretta, would you explore your options and get something a lil more concealable? Decisions, decisions!

      Anyone with some advice and would like to share, please take the conch! Thanks in advance guys!

    2. #2
      Member Broondog's Avatar
      Join Date
      Feb 2013
      Location
      SE Missouri
      Posts
      155
      Sig's (i own a P229) are overrated and over priced in my opinion. are they good guns? yes. are they worth the "status" they seem to have? debatable. you are concerned about external safeties so that nix's the Sig in your book i think. the one feature my Sig has that i really like is the decocker.

      Springfield's - i have no real opinion since i don't own one, never have owned one and have never even fondled one at the fun store. maybe another will chime in on this.

      Glock's (i own a Mdl 22 and a Mdl 27) are, in my opinion, the AK of handguns. they are inexpensive, robust, easy to maintain and reliable. EVERY TIME i pull the trigger on one of mine, it fires. i cannot say that about the 20 other handguns i own. sure they have no external safety but there is an old saying that applies here......"keep your booger hook off of the bang switch until you are ready to fire". that is the most reliable safety you can ever have.

      .40 S&W or .45 ACP? i think the .45 ACP round is overrated as well (ducks the rocks being thrown from the gallery! ). bigger is not always better when talking firearm projectiles (or rocks), but shot placement is. putting rounds center mass is the key and even the lowly .22lr will kill a critter just as dead. still, this is your choice.

      since you live in the communist state of California where the right that shall not be infringed is infringed harder than it is out here in the flyover states, buying a pistol based on concealability is a moot point and seems to me to be a waste of time.

      in the end, go try on all of the pistols that you are considering and get the one that fits you best.

    3. #3
      Member
      Join Date
      Jul 2011
      Posts
      751
      Glock Glock Glock Glock Glock!!!!!!!!!!

      Springfield XDm is good too, just make sure you get the (m) versions, I love the grip on those so much

      Sigs are good but very expensive...! I would get a Sig over a XDm, but for the money you cannot beat a glock

    4. #4
      Banned
      Join Date
      Jan 2012
      Location
      Wisconsin
      Posts
      1,366
      Beretta 96 inox..............

    5. #5
      Banned
      Join Date
      Nov 2012
      Posts
      521
      Quote Originally Posted by jakeleinen1 View Post
      Glock Glock Glock Glock Glock!!!!!!!!!!

      Springfield XDm is good too, just make sure you get the (m) versions, I love the grip on those so much

      Sigs are good but very expensive...! I would get a Sig over a XDm, but for the money you cannot beat a glock
      Glock's are nice, like I stated the safety interlocks aren't really up to snuff. We'll see maybe I need more practice.

      How much roughly are a .40 cal Sig, or a .40 springfield xdm?

    6. #6
      Senior Member paratrooper's Avatar
      Join Date
      Feb 2012
      Posts
      4,812
      I have a Glock 21C, a Sig P250C (.40 cal.) and recently acquired a SA XD-45.

      If I was told that I could only have one, it would be a tough decision. I really do like my SIG for it's compactness and functionality.

      Crap.....I hate having to make decisions.............

    7. #7
      Member Broondog's Avatar
      Join Date
      Feb 2013
      Location
      SE Missouri
      Posts
      155
      Quote Originally Posted by TheLAGuy View Post
      Glock's are nice, like I stated the safety interlocks aren't really up to snuff.
      oh do tell us how they are not up to snuff? are you having trouble with a Glock just going off randomly?

      and the Sig has to be off you list too since i can't for the life of me find ANY sort of safety on my P229 except for the booger hook one.

    8. #8
      Junior Member IBGoodToGo's Avatar
      Join Date
      Feb 2013
      Location
      North Wet WA
      Posts
      7
      If you thought you already confused??? H & K USP Compact. A tough built gun. With the decocker & safety you can carry in a variety of ways.

      DA / SA (with or without safety)
      or
      Cocked & Locked

      Good Luck & Play Safe!

    9. #9
      Member
      Join Date
      Jan 2013
      Location
      Ohio
      Posts
      140
      Quote Originally Posted by Broondog View Post
      oh do tell us how they are not up to snuff? are you having trouble with a Glock just going off randomly?

      and the Sig has to be off you list too since i can't for the life of me find ANY sort of safety on my P229 except for the booger hook one.
      Just for the record, your 229 (and mine too) has several safeties; an intercept notch on the hammer to hold the hammer away from the firing pin to help make the gun drop safe, and catch the hammer as it falls when being decocked, the decocker itself lowers the hammer safely, the disconnector lifts the trigger bar when the slide is moved out of battery to prevent firing out of battery and a firing pin block that prevents the firing pin from moving forward unless the trigger is pulled. And when you holster the 229 you can place your thumb on or alongside the hammer and feel it begin to move rearward if something in the holster, or a misplaced trigger finger gets in between the edge of the holster while still in the trigger guard.

      But I still agree with you; I carry one of two Sigs or a Glock - finger off the trigger keeps the gun from going bang until you want it to - regardless of the mfr.

    10. #10
      Member XD40inAVL's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 2013
      Location
      Asheville, NC
      Posts
      128
      Features and "natural point" made the XD a clear choice for me.

      And I still have issues that "the trigger *_is_* the safety" for glocks. Yea, that makes sense

    11. #11
      Member
      Join Date
      Jan 2013
      Location
      Ohio
      Posts
      140
      Quote Originally Posted by XD40inAVL View Post
      Features and "natural point" made the XD a clear choice for me.

      And I still have issues that "the trigger *_is_* the safety" for glocks. Yea, that makes sense
      Not sure why it doesn't make sense. "The trigger" has been the "safety" for revolvers for many, many years as it is for DA/SA Sigs, for Glocks and several other pistols.

      Knowing and applying the rules of gun safety to gun handling is where the "safe" part comes in, regardless of the gun design. Nothing wrong with an external safety, but that doesn't make guns without them inherently unsafe. However, unsafe gun handling (such as finger on the trigger when not on target) can make any of them a hazard to be around.

    12. #12
      Member Broondog's Avatar
      Join Date
      Feb 2013
      Location
      SE Missouri
      Posts
      155
      Quote Originally Posted by SteamboatWillie View Post
      Just for the record, your 229 (and mine too) has several safeties; an intercept notch on the hammer to hold the hammer away from the firing pin to help make the gun drop safe, and catch the hammer as it falls when being decocked, the decocker itself lowers the hammer safely, the disconnector lifts the trigger bar when the slide is moved out of battery to prevent firing out of battery and a firing pin block that prevents the firing pin from moving forward unless the trigger is pulled. And when you holster the 229 you can place your thumb on or alongside the hammer and feel it begin to move rearward if something in the holster, or a misplaced trigger finger gets in between the edge of the holster while still in the trigger guard.

      But I still agree with you; I carry one of two Sigs or a Glock - finger off the trigger keeps the gun from going bang until you want it to - regardless of the mfr.
      my point was that there is no magical safety switch for the OP to comfort himself with.

    13. #13
      Member
      Join Date
      Jan 2013
      Location
      Ohio
      Posts
      140
      Quote Originally Posted by Broondog View Post
      my point was that there is no magical safety switch for the OP to comfort himself with.
      And I agree. I'm just saying that modern semi-auto handguns generally have several "safeties". So I don't believe that NOT having an external safety on a Glock or Sig makes them any less safe than other service pistols.

      Unless the user follows basic safety rules ANY person (not the gun) can be unsafe using a firearm.

    14. #14
      pic
      pic is offline
      Supporting Member HGF Gold Member

      Join Date
      Nov 2009
      Posts
      3,211
      Mr LAGuy,,you state you already have a full size carry gun. Sounds like you are looking for a more concealable firearm. What mode of carry are you considering? How do you carry your full size px4?
      Is your current mode of carry comfortable?. For the warm summer days what is your mode of carry?

    Sponsored Links

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •  

    Search tags for this page

    p229 overrated
    ,
    springfield .40 vs sig .40 vs berretta .40
    ,

    springfield or glock 2013

    ,
    springfield xdm .40 vs. sig p229 2013 california
    Click on a term to search for related topics.