Handgun Forum banner

If you could only have one gun, one platform and one caliber, what would you choose

  • S&W

    Votes: 52 14.7%
  • Colt

    Votes: 23 6.5%
  • Glock

    Votes: 64 18.1%
  • Ruger

    Votes: 46 13.0%
  • Berretta

    Votes: 40 11.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 128 36.3%

If you could have one gun, one platform, and one caliber, what would it be ?

41K views 160 replies 132 participants last post by  insman1132 
#1 ·
Mine would be a Ruger SP 101 357 MAG 4 in barrel, stainless. Went with a revolver because this would be the only gun I could have. The SP is still concealable with a five shot capacity. Double action so a speed loader or strip for quick reload is an option.
 
#84 ·
That's a tough one! But overall I'd have to say my Kahr MK40, all stainless steel construction, the extra weight helps absorb recoil, large caliber, no external safeties, small flat size makes it easy to conceal unless you are stark naked. Otherwise, I'd probably go with a 1911 in particular my Detonics "Combat Master" .45 ACP all stainless no "mim" parts, can be completely dis-assembled with a minimum of tools or none, most parts are interchangeable with other 1911's, and the shortened grip frame makes it easier to conceal, especially with the addition of "slim" grip panels. On the revolver side I'd go with the S&W Model 640 .357 J-Frame all stainless, easy to conceal and shoot with .38 specials, .357 is another matter! But if needed the gun will handle it, maybe not the shooter! The smallest gun in the largest caliber that you can handle are my top priorities, I like the extra weight that all steel construction provides in these small handguns, they are easier to control and practice with, and their robust construction insures that they won't wear out that quickly. The concealability factor is also paramount if you can only have one gun, you're going to end up wanting or needing to carry it, under all kinds of weather conditions and it's pretty difficult to conceal a full size or intermediate size handgun under a T-Shirt or in ones pocket during the summer, especially where I am in the Southwest. Fortunately, at least for now we are not limited to one gun, although it may come to that, or no gun, at least not legally if certain politicians get their way. WE MUST NEVER LET THAT HAPPEN!!!
 
#87 ·
I don't know about you all but this is just about the same question I seem to be asking myself these days, since I have a limited budget, I assume like most everybody...it was certainly how I approached my defensive needs originally, back when I was a poor youngster... you kinda need to commit to 1 caliber and 1 gun, until you can get a back up for that caliber. It's only after that investment that you can broaden your collection. At this point, I've selected 3 calibers, and have depth in those capacities. If I win the lottery, i'll add a 4th caliber, probably .45. All this said, I would have to agree with the gentleman's point, that it would have to do everything, and my primary need is a ccw piece for always-carry. If shtf wrol, ccw will likely continue to be the primary need. In all other circumstances, I can probably expect to obtain the required firearm for the purpose at hand (hunting, unusual self-defense needs like handicapped or for the wife, target, ...) So, my choice is a Ruger LCP. Small enough to be there, big enough to care. Of course, the question presumes that the ammunition is available. :anim_lol: Handgunner's Prayer: May we always have multiple options available to us all.....
 
#88 ·
Smith and Wesson M1917. .45 ACP revolver. I have the identical Colt version, although I hear the Smiths are slightly better. It'll take any hand load I can make and is built like a bank vault. It's more accurate than any of my revolvers save for my 8 3/8 inch Smith 29 and Python. Even if you buffaloed a ne'er do well with it he'd be singing with the choir invisible.
 
#91 ·
I would take a Glock 17. Its light weight, fires the most popular cartridge around, is almost indestructible, less likely to rust due to polymer frame and tenifer finish on metal parts, has good sight radius for accuracy, etc, etc, etc. if its going to be your one and only handgun that HAS to last this is a choice that cant let you down in my opinion.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top