Which .40 would you buy? And why?? - Page 3

    View Poll Results: Which .40 would you buy...

    Voters
    65. You may not vote on this poll
    • Glock 22

      21 32.31%
    • Smith and Wesson M&P

      31 47.69%
    • Springfield XD-40 service

      13 20.00%
    Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
    Results 41 to 60 of 71
    1. #41
      Junior Member bearone2's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2011
      Location
      arizona
      Posts
      78
      e46sc3:
      commonality with the sig platform if you rotate your carry firearm. if you're just looking for fun, get something new.

      i was against glock's until i fired a friends g19 at the range & never looked back for a hd/sd firearm.

      i never liked the long da pull on the 1st shot with the sigs & carry a g30.
      it's a soft shooter & i was more accurate with the 30 than the 27 it replaced.

    2. #42
      Senior Member SouthernBoy's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 2007
      Location
      Virginia
      Posts
      4,363
      In the .40S&W I have two gen3 Glock 23's, a Glock 27, an M&P 40 (4.25"), an XD40, and a Kahr Elite '98. Of these, the M&P and the Kahr have the best feel to them for me. The M&P 40 is an excellent platform to consider. Just lots of fine choices out there.

    3. #43
      Cat
      Cat is offline
      Member Cat's Avatar
      Join Date
      Apr 2011
      Location
      Jacksonville, Fla./ Levittown, PA
      Posts
      473
      Anyone own the baby desert eagle II. I'm thinking about buying one. No one here in my town, Rents them out. I like to test it be for I buy one. I'm looking at the .40cal. I owned the 50cal be for,I liked it but was not to happy with it. A 45 is way easer to handle. So I sold it,This passed yr.

      To me the .50cal more for show then anything els. Just to much power for a pistol. Rifles are great in a 308. I own a Armalite AR10A4 and is a great rifle. I just got some the new hornady zombie max ammo. Just never know where I may see some Zombies out there.Just have to be prepared for the Zombie Apocalypse...he he.lol...

    4. #44
      Junior Member Bigpoppy's Avatar
      Join Date
      Oct 2008
      Posts
      48
      I have both a Gen4 Glock22 and S&WM&P40. The M&P40 is what I carry with a Crimson trace laser grip. Right now I have a 357Sig barrel in it so it is an M&P357Sig right now. The M&P just points naturally for me when I rip it out of my IWB holster. The Gen4 Glock22 is a very very close second.

    5. #45
      Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2010
      Location
      Western NC
      Posts
      314
      Quote Originally Posted by rex View Post
      I really have little use for the 40 because of it's snappiness and obnoxious blast,you won't have muffs on when you need it.

      Of the 3 you picked I'd have to check out a Smith.I've shot the Glock and handled an XD.Neither feel good to me but the gripsafety on the XD cures one of Glock's big flaws.If the Smith has a safety I would try it no problem.You couldn't give me a Glock,my 1911s are way safer than the 'safe action'.

      If plastic was going to be had,my first choice is HK until the PPQ is proven.If I can save a little more to have a proven quality design,I can't justify saving money for good enough when my life or family's may depend on it.You get what you pay for,it works with guns too with the exception of Kimber.
      Really??? Wow! Heard a few too many horror stories about someone dropping a 1911 or having one put on a table, the table get bumped the gun fall of in the floor and fire. Never heard of it with a Glock. A safety is just a mechanism that is in place, and has a tendency to fail. People rely way to much on that one little piece of machinary. When that happens you take it for granted that it will always function properly. I have seen them stick and not be able to get pushed to fire. Also seen them "on safety" something be wrong with it and the gun still shoot. Much rather rely on keeping my finger off the trigger and the gun pointed away from nothing I don't intend on shooting.

      Of course we won't talk about in a stressful situation the loss of fine motor skills that you will need to work the safety lever, and without proper training/practice the very vast majority will forget to even flip the safety to fire.

      Quote Originally Posted by E46SC3 View Post
      Okay ... so my latest thoughts now no longer include the Springfield or Glock. For that matter ... I've even dropped thinking about a Sig 250c (just not sure I'll like the DAO). Now I'm thinking about a used Sig P226 vs a new M&P 40. My collection as of now is made up of 4 Sigs (P220, 229, 238 & 239 all were new when I bought them). So should I just continue along that road and buy another one or try something different? What do you guys think ...
      Why not just go out and a limb and try it. I mean if you like Sigs and just want to stay in your comfort zone then by all means snatch another. But, since you have 4 already I would say get something different jus tot have fun. I think you will be pleasantly suprised by the M&P.

      Quote Originally Posted by SouthernBoy View Post
      In the .40S&W I have two gen3 Glock 23's, a Glock 27, an M&P 40 (4.25"), an XD40, and a Kahr Elite '98. Of these, the M&P and the Kahr have the best feel to them for me. The M&P 40 is an excellent platform to consider. Just lots of fine choices out there.
      Quote Originally Posted by Bigpoppy View Post
      I have both a Gen4 Glock22 and S&WM&P40. The M&P40 is what I carry with a Crimson trace laser grip. Right now I have a 357Sig barrel in it so it is an M&P357Sig right now. The M&P just points naturally for me when I rip it out of my IWB holster. The Gen4 Glock22 is a very very close second.
      I love you guys *sniff sniff*

    6. #46
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Sep 2011
      Posts
      7
      Why not FNP-40. I've had S&W people guys fall in love with it after shooting it

    7. #47
      Senior Member
      Join Date
      Aug 2010
      Location
      Poughkeepsie, NY
      Posts
      1,017
      Quote Originally Posted by aggie29 View Post
      Why not FNP-40. I've had S&W people guys fall in love with it after shooting it
      I think most would consider this a range gun. So if you are looking for a range gun, fine. But I think it is a bit big and heavy for CC.

    8. #48
      Senior Member dondavis3's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2009
      Location
      Dallas / Fort Worth Texas Area
      Posts
      1,893
      I voted for S&W M&P and I own one.

      But I wouldn't buy a .40 cal.

      I own several, but do not care for the caliber.

      If you want big - I like .45

      If you want inexpensive caliber - then 9mm

      I, like you like Sig Sauer best - you might look at a Sig P220

      Here's mine and it's a tack driver




    9. #49
      rex
      rex is offline
      Senior Member
      Join Date
      Jan 2012
      Location
      FL
      Posts
      1,301
      Those 1911 ND's are rare and suspect,besides most 1911s have been using a FP for over 30 yrs.A spec 1911 will not go off at hip or table height,but an altered trigger group or weak FP spring may cause it,not the original design.Glock's failure is putting the safety in the trigger like it isn't there,a little research will pull up AD's of reholstering and the trigger being tripped.I believe most are negligent but there are cases no finger was involved.My 1911 can not go off unless I make it do so or screw up.

      Forgetting to hit the safety carries no weight for me,the thumb automatically wants to hit it on the draw,the real training is to stop that from happening until you want it off per the situation.I have never missed it let alone forget,even in speed rocks.I figure if someone can't handle a safety,they need a revolver.If a safety is too hard for them they aren't going to handle a stoppage very well at all.

    10. #50
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2011
      Posts
      66
      Okay, first of all I'd like to thank everyone who voted on my poll, and to those who left some feedback on this thread. But, today I finally made my decision about which .40 I would buy. As it turns out, I didn't buy any of the three I put on the poll or for that matter any of the previous Sigs I had spoken about. Each of those firearms are all fine firearms and I'm sure I would have been happy with any of them. But, I just couldn't keep myself from buying another Sig. Well, actually two new Sigs ... First up I purchased a SP2022 as my primary home defense pistol. It was the firearm I chose over the three on my poll. Second up I picked up another P229 only this one is the enhanced elite version. I have always loved how the elites have beavertails, addition slide serrations and the short reset trigger. Can't wait until I get to bring them home. Thanks again everyone!

    11. #51
      Senior Member dondavis3's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2009
      Location
      Dallas / Fort Worth Texas Area
      Posts
      1,893
      Congratulations.

      Man you made 2 great choices

      I own both guns and they are wonderful gun's.

      Post some pictures when you get them

      Did you buy both in .40 cal?


    12. #52
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2011
      Posts
      66
      Quote Originally Posted by dondavis3 View Post
      Congratulations.

      Man you made 2 great choices

      I own both guns and hey are wonderful gun's.

      Post some pictures when you get them

      Did you buy both in .40 cal?

      Thank you Don,

      I'm sure I'll be very happy with both guns. As for pictures ... it might be awhile before I can get to that. Yes, I did buy both in .40 cal. Here in California I can only carry 10rd magazines. So buying a 9mm, didn't have in my option any benefits over .40 cal other than cost of shooting while practicing. I'll look for a good conditioned P228 as my 9mm platform and besides I have my P239 in 9mm.

    13. #53
      Banned
      Join Date
      Jan 2012
      Location
      Wisconsin
      Posts
      1,366
      You didn't buy any of the poll guns? Good for you......

    14. #54
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2011
      Posts
      66
      Quote Originally Posted by berettabone View Post
      You didn't buy any of the poll guns? Good for you......
      No ... I didn't buy any of the three on the poll. I was at that time thinking about trying out something different. I just couldn't get myself to do so. Maybe next time I'll consider a Beretta ...

    15. #55
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Mar 2012
      Posts
      1
      I've had the baby eagle II .40SW semi-compact for a couple of months now ... love everything about it ... especially the feel in my hands

    16. #56
      Member SigP229R's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jun 2007
      Location
      North Carolina
      Posts
      115
      None of the ones you have listed. It would be a Sig P229.

    17. #57
      Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2010
      Location
      Western NC
      Posts
      314
      Quote Originally Posted by berettabone View Post
      None of the above..........Beretta 96.....Sig.........
      Quote Originally Posted by berettabone View Post
      None of the above..........
      Really felt you had to post that twice

      Quote Originally Posted by berettabone View Post
      Well, I just found(after searching for a long time) a Beretta 96 inox w/ all stainless controls...but that's because I love Beretta's.....sounds to me like you are used to shooting Sigs.....I wouldn't mind a 226 myself.......I like the SAS models........sure are nice looking guns......
      NO?!? You don't say. And people think the Glock fanboys are bad.

      Quote Originally Posted by berettabone View Post
      You didn't buy any of the poll guns? Good for you......
      You sure you don't want to rag him for not buying a Beretta aka the bestest gun in the whole wide world

    18. #58
      Junior Member Sabe357's Avatar
      Join Date
      Mar 2012
      Location
      NC
      Posts
      6
      Smith & Wesson M&P for the 40 Smith&Wesson round, great feel and nice to shoot

    19. #59
      Junior Member Sabe357's Avatar
      Join Date
      Mar 2012
      Location
      NC
      Posts
      6
      I have been looking at the Sig P229 Enhanced Elite for some time as my next purchase. Never owned one but I came across it in my search for a good 357 sig pistol and being that it was mostly steel construction, I heard great reviews about shooting the sig out of it. Never had a non-polymer gun, do you think the P229 EE would be a good conceal carry option? Thanks

    20. #60
      Member barstoolguru's Avatar
      Join Date
      Mar 2012
      Posts
      101
      none of your choices .... g23 for me

    Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast

    Sponsored Links

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •  

    Search tags for this page

    beretta 96 vs glock 23 vs xdm

    ,

    glock 22 g4 vs cz p-07 40

    ,

    glock 23 vs m&p 40c

    ,

    glock22 vs m&p40

    ,

    m&p 40 vs glock 23 gen 4

    ,

    m&p 40c vs glock 23

    ,
    m&p 40l versus glock 35 gen 4
    ,

    mp40c or g23

    ,
    ruger sr40c vs springfield xd 40 4
    ,

    what 40 cal h&k would you buy

    ,

    which 40 cal would you buy

    ,
    xdm 40 vs glock 23 vs ruger sr40
    Click on a term to search for related topics.