the .45 is obviously .05 BETTER than the .40
Which do you think is better for a CC? And which pistol do you recommend?
I've had a bunch of both and I prefer the .45ACP, I don't think it's "better" over all, I just prefer the way they shoot for me.
As for what .45s do I recommend for average Joe carry?
Commander and CCO sized 1911s frame various makers
Sig 220 Carry & Compact
Glock 30 & 36
Kahr P45 & PM45
To Be Continued....
45 juz i'm a Man.
i just like my 1911 and it's a 45. Thats my opinion and i'm sticking to it
Does it matter? A 40 you are dead and a 45 you are more dead.
Sig P220; .45 acp.
I agree a 9mm in a +p is all the firepower you will need and a single stack is going to have one more round over a 40 & 45.
The size of the bullet, and even its velocity, is less important than where the bullet hits.
Place 'em well, and it really doesn't matter if it's a 9mm, a .38 Special, a .40, or a .45 ACP. Even a "mere" .380 will do the job, if you hit the right place(s).
Therefore, no matter what you choose to carry, if you don't practice, practice, practice to make yourself proficient with it, you will be outgunned and you will lose.
A high-powered miss is not as good as a wimpy hit.
I've carried a 1911 for so long, and I'm so old, that it would be ill-advised for me to change... so I won't
A .45 is clearly superior when comparing FMJ. The comparison is less clear when it is JHP that you are comparing.
I think both are effective rounds (more effective than a 9mm).
I think it boils down to which gun.
- Which gun can you shoot more accurately?
- Which gun are you likely to have on your person at any given time?
For me, the 1911 in .45 is the most accurate weapon I've ever shot. But it is not a weapon I like to carry. And the smaller, lighter versions in 1911 seem all to have reliability issues.
I like the Glock 27 for carry. The new Nano (Beretta) in .40 caliber reads like a nice weapon and once it is proved reliable I plan on getting one. The Walther PPS also reads like an ideal carry weapon in .40 caliber. But looking at the Walther-specific website (forums) I see too many complaints about the .40 caliber PPS (fewer problems with the 9mm version).
Which weapon are you likely to carry? And can you shoot it well? (And is it reliable.)
Once you get up to at least a 9x19 (9mm Luger), with proper ammo, it's just a matter of shot placement. So, the best SD gun for anyone is simply the one they will practice with the most and feel confident with. I prefer .45, because I like to shoot them, and feel confident with them.
Thank you all. I'm new to shooting and have only shot a 9mm so all the advise is great. Thanks again
I agree with you. I like the .45 better for me.
@ Steve M1911A1
I agree with you also .. practice .. be proficient with your chosen gun.
If you have shot 9mm why go for .40 or .45 stick to 9mm.
The most used and popular pistol and sub machine gun round in the world.