Well, those titanium/scandium revolvers are so light, and the lighter the gun, the more the recoil. I've heard that some of those small allow revolvers han really beat your hand to hell. Generally, the bigger the gun (NOT bigger the caliber), the less the recoil.

Now, the P89 shouldn't really have that heavy of a recoil. I shot one many, many years ago. Seemed ok. Kinda similiar to a Beretta 92's recoil. Usually, the metal framed guns have less recoil than polymer ones.

Try a steel revolver if U want less recoil - maybe a 357 revolver w/ 38 rounds. Make sure U have some rubber grips, though. It makes it more comfortable.

As for semi-autos - I personally think the Beretta 92 has the least amount of recoil out of any 9mm I have ever fired.

I would sooner shoot a hand held cannon than an ultra lightweight snub. Those little beasts kick! See my comments on a 18.5 oz 44 Special they also apply to the 357 snub. Thoughts on the .44 Special revolver........ Regards, Richard

Thanks for the reassurance. Shipwreck, the P89 handles really nice. I don't know if I dare say this in this forum, but I liked it a lot better than the Glock the salesfolk tried to push on me.

I picked up the little S&W because I'm looking for something I might want to carry in the future (I'm waiting for my CCW). I think it would be important that what I carry be something I can actually hit a target with, and not just show in a menacing way, should that ever become necessary.

WM

One of these days, I may pick up a Ruger semi-auto... I think they are a good deal for the $

Two factor affect recoil most: (1) weight of the gun (2) weight of the bullet.

The lightweight revolvers (.38 Special) handle the 95gr and 110gr. bullet loads easiest. Going up in bullet weight, go up in gun weight.

And, I can't recommend rubber grips to anybody. The rubber grips and abrades your hand upon firing. Wood, or better, ivory, will allow the gun to slip slightly and feel far mor comfortable after several rounds have been fired. And those soft grips give the gun a good running start before it hits your palm.

Bob Wright

I have shot 2" & 3" packing revolvers all my life and it's true, they will bite you. When you frist start out, stay away from the hot stuff and work up to the .357's & 44's. My wife hates my Ruger 21/4" but loves to shoot my Phyton 6" barrel with .357's. I can put some mild 38's in the Ruger and she is happy. It's the recoil you got to learn to handle. To be in the X-ring takes a good deal of practice.

I have a DE in 357 and because of it's weight, the recoil is barely noticeable. In the same vein, I have a 30.06 rifle that's all synthetic and it's downright painful to shoot. (IF anybody knows of a decent M1 Garand for sale cheap, let me know!!) In my experience & as others have said, the lighter the gun, the more felt recoil. I guess sacrifices or concessions must be made someplace.

Originally Posted by Thor

In my experience & as others have said, the lighter the gun, the more felt recoil. I guess sacrifices or concessions must be made someplace.

My dad always told me that there isn't any free lunch! Power vs. recoil / weight vs recoil / Bullet weight vs Recoil / Bullet weight vs speed / Speed vs noise / barrel length vs concealibility / size vs handiness / size vs concealibility, / size of ammo vs number of rounds in the mag.
The whole world revolves on compromise. If it didn't I would have a super concealible sub compact .45 that fired from 20 round mags with super accuracy and great knockdown power but no recoil.

Kinda like all those other folks said.........shoot the biggest gun (not necessarily caliber) you can conceal (if that's what you're buying it for). That P89 might be a real good starter, all steel, 9mm low recoil, and it CAN be concealed if you buy a good pancake or IWB holster (emphasis on "good"). In my way of thinking, the snubs are good for one thing, to use when there is absolutely nothing else. Shoot light loads to practice, load it up with self defence loads and carry it a LOT. I liked my P89 a lot.