Having both a Hi Power and several 1911s, I would opt for the Colt, the Hi Power can have a tendency to "bite" the web of the hand, until you have an opportunity try one out, go with the Colt.

Thanks VA...I mentioned that "bite" to the owner cause Ive read that others have said the same thing..owner laughed and said yep it happens.. but you'll only do it once....http://www.handgunforum.net/images/s.../icon_eyes.gif

Both will hold thier valvue, the browning will cost less at the range but the Colt will hit the target harder. I like the 45 acp better.

Thanks for your input... I know hard to tell without seeing them but is the pricing right for these two guns?

Originally Posted by sammi

Thanks for your input... I know hard to tell without seeing them but is the pricing right for these two guns?

If they're in great shape, I'd say yes.
As a new shooter you might find the 9mm a bit more gentle and a lot more cheaper to shoot. YMMV. Would like to see photos when you make your choice.

I'd spend the extra $$ and go for the colt. Every collection should have a nice Colt 1911 in it. IMO

Definitely purchase the colt 1911a1 series 80 for the following reasons:
1. The .45 acp is a proven cartridge for stopping "zombies"
2. It is the easiest to modify or hot-rod to your personal tastes.
3. Brownell's prints & distributes for free a "1911 catalog" just for this pistol & not for the hp.

I have several of both, caliber not withstanding I prefer the 1911 design most so would opt for the 1911 first then get the BHP later

Both are excellent guns an will hold their value.

Right now I personally own a Kimber and a Colt Mark IV officers model in .45 acp.

My Colt



I have not owned, but have shot a lot the Browning HP that my friend owns.

I am prejudiced toward the Colts.

I vote for the Colt.