I think they're all good choices so it boils down to how you feel. I generally know without a doubt when I'm going to buy a gun... it's kinda like the light-bulb lighting up in the old cartoons. Only question I wonder about is if you've tried a S&W M&P? They're pretty much state-of-the-art now for double-stacks in that price range... I like 'em a lot and they're extremely reliable.