which to reach for first .357 or 45acp

    Results 1 to 17 of 17
    1. #1
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2008
      Location
      Arkansas
      Posts
      72

      which to reach for first .357 or 45acp

      If I am carrying both a Kahr CW45 with 6 rounds and a S&W 340 in .357 with 5 rounds, Assuming I am equally proficient with both and both are easily accessible which would you go for first in a situation where deadly force is warranted. I guess what I am asking is which is "ballisticly" (sp?) speaking more likely to neutralize the threat easiest?

    2. #2
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Nov 2008
      Location
      Arkansas
      Posts
      72
      anyone...

    3. #3
      Member xjclassic's Avatar
      Join Date
      May 2008
      Location
      Florence, SC
      Posts
      140
      This may not be the answer you are looking for but here you go. I personally believe it has less to do with the round used or gun it was fired from but more on how well it is used. Good shot placement with either of the guns you have mentioned are going to be more than efficient.

      Edit: Left out that I would reach for the Kahr. Only because I am more comfortable with an automatic than a revolver. Just don't care for the feel of a revolver.

    4. #4
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Feb 2009
      Location
      Cheyenne, WY
      Posts
      55
      I would reach for whichever u are more comfortable with. 5 shots of 45 or 357 is more than enough if placed where they should be. So it all falls with you and what gun u like better.

    5. #5
      Senior Member Bisley's Avatar
      Join Date
      Aug 2008
      Location
      East Texas
      Posts
      2,318
      They are equally effective. Any difference in the effect either would have on a human being is not worth mentioning...depending on how each is loaded, of course.
      Of course, a carefully placed 9mm will likely produce a very similar result.

      Between the two guns you mentioned...I wouldn't be carrying both, but if I was...either one would be fine, unless I was noticeably better at shooting one than the other.

    6. #6
      Member Spartan's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 2006
      Posts
      635
      Whichever has more bullets.

    7. #7
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Jan 2009
      Location
      Middle Tennessee
      Posts
      14
      I'm going to assume a major element here...namely, that you have had NO warning and you are in an "immediate" action mode. If that's a fair assessment, then I personally would go for the wheel gun. Why? Because no thought is needed as to whether or not you have a safety or a cartridge chambered...but that's just me.

    8. #8
      Member Black Metal's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 2008
      Location
      Utah
      Posts
      272
      Quote Originally Posted by JasBrit View Post
      I'm going to assume a major element here...namely, that you have had NO warning and you are in an "immediate" action mode. If that's a fair assessment, then I personally would go for the wheel gun. Why? Because no thought is needed as to whether or not you have a safety or a cartridge chambered...but that's just me.
      Kahrs have no external safety. My wifes Kahr is always loaded so there is no thought of if it will go bang or not

    9. #9
      Member clanger's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 2009
      Location
      So. Cal.
      Posts
      515
      In the home?

      I'd use a home-defense round in either. Or, risk killing the kids in the other room and/or losing your hearing forever, esp with a full-house round in the .357.

      Which one? Which ever one is closest at the time.

    10. #10
      Junior Member dblshred's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 2009
      Location
      unincorporated King County, WA
      Posts
      32
      I used to have a great website bookmarked which dealt with this topic. Unfortunately, it became infected with a virus, my anti-virus kept predicting dire consequences for visiting, so I deleted it. This website tested different calibers with different cartridges, and gave a stopability/lethality rating expressed as a percentage.

      In the .357 Sig caliber, there were two cartridges that were given a 96% rating- the highest of all calibers. One cartridge in .40 also achieved 96%. The highest in .45 was 94%, and the highest in 9mm was 91%.

      I know this will stir the pot a bit, so I'll do some research to see if I can find the site again.

    11. #11
      Junior Member dblshred's Avatar
      Join Date
      Jan 2009
      Location
      unincorporated King County, WA
      Posts
      32
      My apologies- the highest rating went to .357 magnum, not .357 Sig!

      I found the site again, and received no virus warnings. Click here to see it.

    12. #12
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Dec 2008
      Posts
      52
      Whichever you feel most comfortable with.

    13. #13
      Member
      Join Date
      Apr 2007
      Posts
      982
      Quote Originally Posted by Blackmagic14 View Post
      If I am carrying both a Kahr CW45 with 6 rounds and a S&W 340 in .357 with 5 rounds, Assuming I am equally proficient with both and both are easily accessible which would you go for first in a situation where deadly force is warranted. I guess what I am asking is which is "ballisticly" (sp?) speaking more likely to neutralize the threat easiest?
      Since you are equally proficient, then whichever round you use that puts the most ft/lbs on target would be the one more likely to be "ballisticly" efficient.

      Without knowing what your loads are, there is no way to answer your question. However, you can answer your question yourself by looking at ballistic tables from manufacturers published data....

    14. #14
      Junior Member
      Join Date
      Feb 2009
      Location
      central VT
      Posts
      51
      I think I would ask the thug your going to shoot and see how big of a hole he would like to have, then use the other one instead because you should never listen to a bad guy in your living room!!!!

    15. #15
      Senior Member tony pasley's Avatar
      Join Date
      May 2006
      Location
      clyde n.c.
      Posts
      2,815
      The real answer is, which ever one you hit the target with! 1,000 misses does not make up for 1 good hit on the target. Make, model, caliber, or barrel length doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is rounds in the target.

    16. #16
      Member
      Join Date
      Apr 2008
      Posts
      236
      I'd reach for the .357. I know if someone broke in and I wanted a gun that looked nasty and put out a nasty round, I'd grab my snubby S&W mod. 66-4. Most of my friends think that's the scariest looking of my guns, so I'd be hoping that I could avoid shooting someone if I could scare them instead of shooting them; taking a life or shooting someone is not on my list of things to do.

      In regards to the actual round, I'd say they're pretty comparable. Both are considered big rounds. I dunno the ballistics of each but I know the .357 is generally a slow moving round with a lot of momentum and I believe the .45acp is similar.

    17. #17
      Member banjar's Avatar
      Join Date
      Dec 2008
      Location
      North Carolina
      Posts
      603
      In this situation I would not be thinking anything about caliber, what is my favorite I would grab whatever was the closest to me.

    Sponsored Links

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •