View Poll Results: Which 45 for non CCW?

Voters
29. You may not vote on this poll
  • XD45

    18 62.07%
  • Glock 21SF

    11 37.93%
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 26 to 37 of 37
  1. #26
    JONSCH's Avatar
    JONSCH is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    65
    Quote Originally Posted by PhilR. View Post
    If this is the case, then I would vote "neither". Since you already seem to have some modern hi-capacity auto's, why get a third? Why not get something really different?

    There are a few firearms that seem to be universal. IOW, the ones that everyone should have, or no one should be without. One example is a decent .22 handgun. Another example, if one is going to have a .45acp, is the 1911. Everyone should have a 1911 at some point in their lives. 1911's are a classic design, are fun to shoot, easily found, endlessly customizable, and often have great triggers and excellent accuracy. They are just a whoot to shoot as well. I think the government should give every able-bodied adult one (ok, not really, but you get the idea).

    If you are still stuck on the idea of a boringly-reliable poly auto, then just get the one that fits your hand the best, as there are really no other defining characteristics that make one pistol better than the other.

    PhilR.

    people in europe do not like 1911 guns. mostly just an american thing.

  2. Ads
  3. #27
    PhilR. is offline Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    982
    Quote Originally Posted by JONSCH View Post
    people in europe do not like 1911 guns. mostly just an american thing.
    Where in Europe do you live?

    PhilR.

  4. #28
    Dredd is offline Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    267
    I'm not much of a fan when it comes to Glock in anything other than 9mm. So I voted the XD. I do like the XD, but I decided I like my HKs better and for a CCW gun, my G19.

  5. #29
    junkit_boy is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    86
    The G19 is a pretty cool gun. Its probably the only Glock that can fit my hand comfortably. HK is really expensive (i live in calif.) I went to Bass Pro today and gripped a couple of guns. The XD does feel nice compared to most of the 45s out there. They had the FNP9.. nice grip..but it felt really cheap... not soild. So, I think I'm going pick up a XD45 compact. If I ever get a full size 45 I might get a 1911 or a P220 since I love Sig Products..and CZ too!

  6. #30
    submoa is offline Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    784
    Quote Originally Posted by junkit_boy View Post
    The gun is for shooting target and home defense.
    If this is your requirement why have you limited yourself to high cap polymer guns?

    My opinion is that polymer provides a compromise of reduced cost, light weight and comfort at the cost of greater recoil and imperfect triggers. Generally, this trade off is a no brainer for CCW, but this is not your intent.

    If you absolutely must have a high-cap .45 and must stay under $1,000, then you might want to consider Para Ordnance high cap 1911s (P14-45). Although not the best 1911, the trigger and recoil management will be superior to the Glock and XD.

  7. #31
    TOF's Avatar
    TOF
    TOF is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Northern Arizona
    Posts
    3,015
    I would think the full size XD would be better for both HD and Target. Have you added CCW to your requirement?

    I do believe the XD is the better choice.

  8. #32
    junkit_boy is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    86
    CCW are not allowed in California...for the most part.
    This gun is strickly for range practice and home protection. Calif sucks

  9. #33
    junkit_boy is offline Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    86
    Just came back from the Gun Store. I tried out a couple of 1911s. I can see why they are the pride and true. Nice contour and all metal components feel solid. I'm strongly consider your suggestion Phil...thanks

  10. #34
    JeffWard's Avatar
    JeffWard is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    St Pete Beach, FL
    Posts
    1,932
    Here's my XD45 at approx 7yds...



    The Glocks are accurate too, but you can't bitch about this 10-shot group...

    Jeff

  11. #35
    billt's Avatar
    billt is offline Banned
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Glendale, Arizona
    Posts
    116
    One thing the XD is superior to the Glock in is handle diameter and that's only for people with short fingers. That's it. Now with the introduction of the Model 21/SF even that reason doesn't hold. Other reasons given to the XD's superiority are subjective to opinion and nothing else.
    A few of the given 'reasons' XDs are better:

    Price.

    The Glock is about $80 more than the XD. I don't know many people who think $80 is something to worry about with something that protects your life. I just put $80.00 worth of gas in my truck this morning.

    Machining quality/manufacture.

    At the indoor range I shoot at they have XDs come back for warranty work (sometimes complete replacement due to inability to repair). Cracked frames, ftf, stovepiping, chambers needing to be honed. The list goes on and on.

    Durability.

    Like the aforementioned reason - it's false. Most people have this opinion based on only having a few thousand (if that) rounds through their XDs. At the range they are constantly having problems with their XD rentals (see previous reason problems) while Glocks usually run about 100,000 rounds through them before they cycle a new one into the mix. Those are 100,000 trouble free rounds. Consistently. Wait a few more years when all of these XDs get some real use.

    Ergonomics.

    XD likes to tout this one in their advertising as well saying that when you point it the sights line up rather than having you look at the top of the slide. Glock went with their 105 degree handle angle for a reason: they tested, tested and did some more testing and found that it provided the best firing results for accuracy and following shots. The XD's handle angle along with its high barrel axis to the hand provide much more muzzle flip than a Glock which in turn means less accurate double-taps and a less control.

    Single action vs double action.

    The Glock uses the double action for safety. It's one of the reasons it's called Safe-Action. If the striker spring isn't cocked - it can't fire! Just like a down hammer. The XD has a cocked spring. You can count on replacing the striker spring many more times in an XD than a Glock because of this. You also better hope your firing pin block is in proper working order or you're at the mercy of the poorly designed sear of the XD which, by the way, will fire out of battery. Try pushing back on the slide sometime while pulling the trigger. The double action might not be as smooth, clean or as short a pull of the single action, but these are service pistols not target pistols.

    The slide lock.

    The slide lock on the Glock is designed to be tight against the frame and slide as to not be snagged on anything. They also wanted people to use two hands to release the slide because it's a more controlled manner than hitting the lock with your thumb. This isn't the movies! Release the slide the proper way. The slide lock on the XD also adds a decent amount to the overall width of the weapon - not very carry friendly.

    Finish.

    Tenifer is not the outside coating. Tenifer is the metal treatment of the slide and barrel itself. It is .005 mm thick and is close the the hardness of diamond. The treatment of the metal itself achieves a 99.9% salt water resistance. Tenifer is also illegal in this country because the EPA. XD does not have it. Don't regularly oil the slide on your XD and carry it in a cold climate for a while. The in/out condensation will rust your slide in no time.

    Warranty.

    Good thing Springfield has you covered here, you're going to need it.

    Field stripping.

    The Glock actually uses a faster process which uses less steps than the XD. Also, many people rotate the take-down lever then pull the slide lock down putting all forward inertia of the slide to come to a halt against the sear (it's the only thing keeping the slide from going forward at that point) and cause damage to the sear, striker and frame.

    Loaded chamber indicator.

    Glock has this as well.

    Cocked indicator.

    Glock has this as well. If the trigger is forward on a Glock, it's cocked. Also, how are you going to get a round into the chamber on either of these guns without it being cocked? It's not a Walther with a decocker.

    Grip safety.

    How is a gun going to go off without your hand on the handle? Your finger should never be inside the trigger guard unless you have the weapon acquired and intend to fire. Are we forgetting some basic firearm rules? The grip safety is null and void.

    Customization.

    If you can't find genuine Glock custom parts for your Glock at your local gun dealer, you need to find a new one. Glock holsters, parts and accessories are everywhere. Try to find a holster for your XD. It's much more difficult. Yes, it's newer and takes a while, but companies will be reluctant to make them because Springfield supplies you with one, albeit a horrible one with not one level of retention.
    I felt the need to debunk these XD/Glock myths. The XD is not even close the being up to par with the Glock. The Glock is going on 20 years now and has changed the world of pistols - the XD won't make that sort of impact. Bill T.

  12. #36
    hideit's Avatar
    hideit is offline Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    west chester ohio
    Posts
    1,498
    maybe if enough people buy the XD and M&P's and the model 21 & 30 sales go way way south....then maybe
    Glock will come out with a full size single stack 45.
    This is so long overdue it isn't funny......

    Glock can spend $1-2M each year for the last 2-3 years for a RACE CAR sponsorship advertisement but not put out a single stack 45.....

  13. #37
    billt's Avatar
    billt is offline Banned
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Glendale, Arizona
    Posts
    116
    They are selling so many 21's and 21 SF's why should they? When it comes to ammo compacity, very few agree that "less is more". Besides, they already have the Model 36 for someone who wants a slim framed, carry .45. Don't sell Glocks marketing short. Few, if any companies, have sold more handguns in the last 20 years. Bill T.

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Ads

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Search tags for this page

glock 21 accuracy group size

,

glock 21 for sale california

,
glock 21 vs xd45 for ccw
,

glock 21sf accuracy

,
glock 21sf fire out of battery
,
glock 21sf for sale in iowa
,

glock 21sf in glendale az forsale

,
how do you clean a glock 21sf
,

how to clean glock 21 sf

,
the price of a glock 21 sf in los angeles
,

xd 45 shoots high

,
xd45 or glock for ccw?
Click on a term to search for related topics.