I voted Glock for this reason. It is the cheapest.
All three you mentioned are good and all will do the job.
If you have to use it the coppers are gonna get it for a long time.
So let em have the Glock.
No disrespect for Police Officers, but they do like that name.

So far my opinions tend to agree with the polls that I have participated in. I chose the Sig, but also because the Glock's polygonal barrels have a problem with lead bullets. I like having the option to shoot any bullets that I may have at the time.

I voted sig but would get the P229

Originally Posted by Slowfire

So far my opinions tend to agree with the polls that I have participated in. I chose the Sig, but also because the Glock's polygonal barrels have a problem with lead bullets. I like having the option to shoot any bullets that I may have at the time.

The Baby Eagle is also made with polygonal rifling except for a short period (2006 i think) when they went to traditional grooves

I voted for the Sig here. I hate glock so Sig was the obvious choice. The baby eagle does not hold as many rounds, nor do i think it is as reliable as the Sig. really this is just a preference poll, as usual. So my official advice to you would be to buy the one that YOU like best. You're the one who is going to be stuck with it...

Sig is still way out front still eh? I guess people are seeing that bore axis stuff is about as useful a term as stopping power

Let me help you decide!

let me put it this way..as blunt as it is..The SIG P226 is the king of all..period..Any Questions?

Sig is one of the best around. That would be my choice, hands down.

Did you decide???
If you are looking for a CPO drop me a PM I know some good deals out there!

Originally Posted by Dsig1

I'm looking for a sturdy, accurate .40 S&W. The primary use will be target shooting and home defense. This will not be a carry gun. Any and all comments welcome. I've shot all three guns before and like them all. The 226 would be my only SA/DA that I would own but I do like it the best of these 3 in SA mode. Thanks for any suggestions.

Like MauiWowie22 says, "Did you decide???"
its been a year, I hope you got the Sig.

Originally Posted by jc27310

Like MauiWowie22 says, "Did you decide???"
its been a year, I hope you got the Sig.

See Post #18.

Originally Posted by skibum2

See Post #18.

LOL... way back on page one huh?
<

Thanks skibum2!

I voted Sig P226, but I'd like to add one to the list. I bought a SP2022 2 months ago, and it's now my favorite Sig, not to mention my favorite handgun ever. Plus, it's more affordable than the others.

Go with the SIG!

i just purchased the baby eagle and absolutely love it.. it its great in my hand and its accurate

I've only have 1 gun but I've held the sig p229 in a .40 SW at the gun store about....oh 1272 times this past month. Something about the sig feels so right in my hand and I love the decocker and SA option for target shooting. I've only recently come to appreciate glocks but if it was "me" I'd go Sig P229 in .40 SW

I really, really like my SIG P226 Elite .40, but lately I have become even more attached to my CZ P06 .40.

I would picked the sig p226 because it's smooth like a Cadillac and it's going to be my 2nd handgun that I am going to get in .40 cal. Good luck!

Go SIG or GLock.

If you baby your guns or a scratch is going to drive you insane go Glock...

Otherwise SIG.

I'm new, but I'm sure you know my vote already.

I said Sig, but its really up to which one you will carry and shoot well...
Just my .02

I didn't vote because I feel all 3 are great guns. I have a sig and a baby eagle and enjoy shooting both. I don't have a glock (yet) but have shot plenty and love them. So either direction you go with is a good one