Which caliber to buy?

Hello Everyone!

I am getting ready to purchase my first handgun. I have chosen to go with Glock as the manufacture of choice. The gun will be carried into the woods for protection against large animals such as cougars and bear. Of course it will be carried as personal defense as well. My question is which caliber would be best for the application. Originally I thought a .45 would do the job but a couple people pointed out that a 10mm has better ballistic numbers. Although it travels faster etc than a .45cal the .45 has more mass. So wouldn't the .45 hit harder than the 10mm? So does the 10mm penetrate better? Can you please set me straight.... Thanks!

your question is a difficult one.
My overly simplified answer may not be of help.
Traveling about as I do; I can go into about any ?country store? and purchase .22's-.38-.357-.45 without too much sweat.
When I'm looking for .380's-.41's-sometimes 9mm: it doesn't happen.
Standards are available without ?big city? shopping.

Walk-abouts require forethought and reasoning. My reasoning, simplifications.

10mm with loadings from double tap.

Here's the ballistics table for Double Tap ammo and the reason I feel their 10mm is the best. http://www.10mmtalk.com/index.php?showtopic=1393

"Hitting harder" or penetration is due to several variables, and not just on caliber alone. The total amount of energy delivered to the target goes up with increased velocity, or increased mass. IOW, a slow large bullet might not hit as hard as a smaller bullet traveling at a high speed.

Penetration also depends on bullet construction, rather than the caliber itself.

I would not carry a 10mm if I were worrying about bear. While 10mm loads such as the powerful offerings from Double Tap and Buffalo Bore will handle most four-legged critters and just about any two-legged ones, I would not consider it adequate for bear. Don't get me wrong -- I would use a 10mm against a bear if it was the only thing I had, but it wouldn't be the one I would go out and purchase beforehand. If it were me, I would want something in the 1k or higher ft/lb range....

PhilR.

if it was for double duty or black bears i would say the glock 20 in 10mm but for a grizzly bear defense gun i would want a .454 casul or .500 smith and wesson

Any pistol powerful enough to reliably stop a bear is also a poor choice for a first handgun. Any such gun will recoil hard enough to be severely detrimental to your ability to learn to shoot accurately. Don't depend on misses to stop bears.

Thanks everyone!

I live in eastern WA so it would be to defend against black bear and cougars if anything. So would either the .45 or 10mm be up to the job? I think I would rather own/carry a .45 just for the fact that ammunition is widely available. Anyway, as a military guy I have shot a few weapons and not to worried about being able to hit my target. :-) Besides there is an indoor range just a couple miles from my house so I can get plenty of pratice in...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thercman

Thanks everyone!

I live in eastern WA so it would be to defend against black bear and cougars if anything. So would either the .45 or 10mm be up to the job? I think I would rather own/carry a .45 just for the fact that ammunition is widely available. Anyway, as a military guy I have shot a few weapons and not to worried about being able to hit my target. :-) Besides there is an indoor range just a couple miles from my house so I can get plenty of pratice in...

---

10mm would be more potent than .45 in general.

As a sidearm for protection from wildlife, especially bear, I wouldn't want either a 10mm or a .45. I'd want a .44 (at the least) on my hip.

My "First" handgun was a Ruger Single Six. I built a foundation in gun handling with it. Got some help from people in the know. Watched all the police pistol videos I could find at the time,(1983). Then I went for a Ruger Redhawk .44 mag. It did recoil a triffle, but not unmanagable. Like was mentioned earlier, this isn't a "packer" as far as conceilment. But I would feel better with it in bear country than say a 10mm or .45ACP. From there I went to a Ruger Blackhawk Hunter. Again the .44 mag. I loaded 300grain soft points over H110 to carry for black bear here in PA. Never felt under gunned. But then, there wasn't a 460 or 500 available at the time. If you serriously feel you need a bear / cougar hand gun, then base your decision on that. You can pick up a c.c. piece for a very reasonable price if you shop around a bit. I guess the big question is, what are you most likely to be attacked by. A bear or a person? The .44 mag is a very flexible round. Loads from 180gr on up to 300 if you feel the need. I shot a truck load of hard cast 250gr Keith type semi wadcutters in mine. The 180gr HP got the vote for protection duty. Take care and shoot straight,R.J.

Considering the uses you posit for your first handgun, it seems that a revolver, probably in .357 would be the best bet. You can always shoot 38 special in it when you desire. Smith and Wesson, or Ruger would be good choices. Revolvers are easy to learn on, and more forgiving from the aspect of safety than semi-autos. They are also available in calibers, specifically .357 and larger, that can cope effectively with large animals of all persuasions. Good luck on your choice!

If your primary use for it is bear/couger protection, I would probably choose a redhawk in .44 mag. A 4 inch barrel would carry well.

Whoa, whoa, whoa, back the truck up son.:mrgreen:
If this is your first pistol, you better start with a 9mm or .45.
Yes the 10mm is powerful, but you need to hit what your aiming at and do so rapidly. I suppose you could always use softer loads if the full power's were too much.
I've heard animal killers say they couldn't really see a difference between the 10mm and the 9mm when it came to stopping power. The 10mm will give you great penetration though.
Take care

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mike Barham

Any pistol powerful enough to reliably stop a bear is also a poor choice for a first handgun. Any such gun will recoil hard enough to be severely detrimental to your ability to learn to shoot accurately. Don't depend on misses to stop bears.

---

I'll go you one better Mike. I was stationed around Kodiak and Adak for awhile and I have killed bears (big ones) not for sport but for nuisance causing. Winchester .338 Magnum in a damn good rifle is the minimum for reliable killing of big bears. If you are armed with any kind of handgun your best accessory is a fast pair of running shoes. I hear a lot around the forums about backups for bear. Another Marine with a .416 Rigby H&H is the only best backup. Avoid bears at all costs, lots bigger and tougher than most people realize!

Primary Roll: Personal Defense (once or twice per year in case of bear): Buy a 45ACP, or 9mm, or 40 S&W that you can shoot frequently and well.

Primary Roll: Bear Country Woods Gun (occasional carry for defense against 2-legged opposition): Buy a 44Mag MINIMUM. Preferably a 460 Mag, that you can carry 45 Long Colt in for smaller stuff.

First time shooter? Buy a good 9mm, and stay the hell away from bears...


My 2 cents.

JW

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wjh2657

I'll go you one better Mike. I was stationed around Kodiak and Adak for awhile and I have killed bears (big ones) not for sport but for nuisance causing. Winchester .338 Magnum in a damn good rifle is the minimum for reliable killing of big bears. If you are armed with any kind of handgun your best accessory is a fast pair of running shoes. I hear a lot around the forums about backups for bear. Another Marine with a .416 Rigby H&H is the only best backup. Avoid bears at all costs, lots bigger and tougher than most people realize!

---

Jarheads rarely talk so sensibly! :mrgreen:

Seriously, this is very good advice. Handguns are weak and hard to shoot well. If one is seriously concerned about bears, a rifle is absolutely the way to go. We can quibble about which rifle (I'd probably go with something like Jim West's Co-Pilot or a Marlin Guide Gun with modern ammo), but the fact remains that if one is serious about stopping a big bear, one needs a rifle and not some puny pistol. Pistols aren't even that good at stopping relatively weak, thin-skinned, lightly-boned people - never mind big bears.

On the other hand, if one uses some common sense, the chances of running up against an aggressive bear are fairly small. But a lot of guys think they look cool roaming the forests with a pistol, and a rifle is just so inconvenient. :mrgreen:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JeffWard

Primary Roll: Personal Defense (once or twice per year in case of bear): Buy a 45ACP, or 9mm, or 40 S&W that you can shoot frequently and well.

First time shooter? Buy a good 9mm, and stay the hell away from bears...

JW

---

+1 on the stay away from bears...Have to agree with Jeff, on the handguns for self defense. Go with a Really BIG rifle for the bears. :smt023

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JeffWard

First time shooter? Buy a good 9mm, and stay the hell away from bears...

---

Excellent advice.

He did say black bears didn't he (and cougars)? That's a whole other ball game. Minimum would be a .357........ + a wheel gun makes a great first gun....... + a .357 can shoot 38's for practice and HD (as already mentioned earlier).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fred40

He did say black bears didn't he (and cougars)? That's a whole other ball game. Minimum would be a .357........ + a wheel gun makes a great first gun....... + a .357 can shoot 38's for practice and HD (as already mentioned earlier).

---

Agreed on black bears, which are relatively small and weak compared to their brown cousins. Doesn't make a handgun any easier to shoot well compared to a rifle, though. :mrgreen:

Nothing beats a rifle in bear country (12 gauge with 00 buck or slugs as my second choice) but for pistols I would say .357 mag.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fred40

He did say black bears didn't he (and cougars)? That's a whole other ball game. Minimum would be a .357........ + a wheel gun makes a great first gun....... + a .357 can shoot 38's for practice and HD (as already mentioned earlier).

---

+1

Try a S&W 686 or 627

Went salmon fishing in Alaska once...

I'm paraphrasing from the back of the Alaska State Fishing License:

"It is recommended, when fishing in bear country, to carry a .308 or more powerful rifle at all times, as the bears may contest YOUR right to THEIR fish."

We had a Remington .308 pump (my low-land deer gun), loaded up w/ 185gr soft-nose ammo.

I'd only use a pistol on a brown bear if it was that, or death...

Jeff

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JeffWard

I'd only use a pistol on a brown bear if it was that, or death...

---

Frank was excited about his new rifle and decided to try bear hunting. He spotted a small brown bear and shot it. Right after, there was a tap on his shoulder and he turned around to see a big black bear. The black bear said, "That was my cousin and you've got two choices... Either I maul you to death or we have sex."

After considering briefly, Frank decided to accede to the latter alternative. Even though he felt sore for two weeks, Frank soon recovered and vowed revenge.

He headed out on another trip where he found the black bear and shot it. Right after, there was another tap on his shoulder. This time a huge grizzly bear stood right next to him. The grizzly said, "That was a big mistake, Frank. That was my cousin and you've got two choices. Either I maul you to death or we have rough sex." Again, Frank thought it was better to cooperate.

Although he survived, it took several months before Frank finally recovered. Outraged, he headed back to the woods, managed to track down the grizzly and shot it. He felt sweet revenge, but, then, there was a tap on his shoulder. He turned around to find a giant polar bear standing there. The polar bear looked at him very sadly and said, "Admit it Frank, you don't come here for the hunting, do you?"

Speaking of jokes and bears....

If one is going to spend time in bear country, one should tie small bells on your shoelaces, so that a bear can hear you coming and therefore won't be surprised. You should also carry pepper spray, if you should be so unfortunate to come in close contact with a bear.

You should also learn the signs of recent bear activity. The presence of feces can tell you if there are bears nearby. You should also learn how to tell what kind of bears there might be nearby. Black bear feces is smaller and has little bits of leaves and berries in it. Grizzly bear feces has little bells in it, and smells like pepper.....

PhilR.