That's not a hard question. Smith & Wesson J-frame .38, enclosed or shrouded hammer. Of the three choices, steel/aluminum/titanium, aluminum is probably the best compromise, titanium is only for serious masochists (like me). Steel is easier to shoot, but harder to carry in a pocket without dragging your pants down.

Second choice, Taurus copy of the Smith & Wesson.

As milquetoast pointed out, you can't go wrong with a j-frame size .38. But you must take into consideration the build of your body. I'm 5'8" 175 lbs. and although I carry quite a few different handguns, I am most fond of my S&W K frame Model 19. I have the ole' "narrow waist,broad shoulder" build and can conceal most duty sized handguns as easy as I can a J frame. So take in to account your build and body size when making your selection as well as what type of holster you're going to be using. I prefer IWB (inside the waistband) holsters to all else but that's me. Good luck to ya'.

My own choice is the Smith & Wesson Model 19 Combat Magnum in 2 1/2" barrel and stocked with Eagle Secret Service grips:


Its the centerpiece.

Bob Wright

Originally Posted by Bob Wright

My own choice is the Smith & Wesson Model 19 Combat Magnum in 2 1/2" barrel and stocked with Eagle Secret Service grips:


Its the centerpiece.

Bob Wright

I am with you on this one Bob. The M-19 is my all time favorite carry revolver. I did carry a lot of different J-frames and Colts also as back then I done a lot of trading.

i carry a s&w 642 in pocket holster and also owb i am very satistied with it. many years ago i carried a s&w m19 2 1/2 but like the fool i am i sold it.

For pocket carry 340pd all the time and when I am wearing shorts I also carry my 325SC in 45acp in an owb holster.

Don't forget about the Ruger SP101 (or the GP100 for that matter).

Don't forget about the Charter Arms .44 Bulldog, or the Taurus 5 shot
.44 spl. The .44 spl. is an excellent cartridge!

Bottom line: find a gun that fits your hand, because you will be able to
control it better than one that doesn't fit.

Good luck and have fun looking for a new gun!