Handgun Forum banner

FAV REVOLVER CALIBER

  • 22LR

    Votes: 31 3.8%
  • .357MAG

    Votes: 485 59.1%
  • .41MAG

    Votes: 23 2.8%
  • .44MAG

    Votes: 96 11.7%
  • 45ACP

    Votes: 27 3.3%
  • 460MAG

    Votes: 3 0.4%
  • 480

    Votes: 1 0.1%
  • 500

    Votes: 8 1.0%
  • OTHER

    Votes: 147 17.9%

favorite caliber for revolvers

46K views 198 replies 162 participants last post by  Oldman11 
#1 ·
which caliber is the most popular for revolvers
 
#53 ·
They are all good. Just depends one what bullet you load in them. Will say however that with a good hunting bullet in the .357 such as a 180 gr. LBT, will do as well on big game as a standard Keith style bullet from a .44 mag. However it's hard to beat a heavily loaded .45 Colt with a heavy (340 gr.) LBT style, hard cast for hunting big game. Used this for years, but have since gone back to the .357 in a strong (Ruger)revolver. The smaller grip frame, and mild recoil; even when loaded heavy; is easier for me, to make accurate shots at longer ranges in my hands.
 
#54 ·
All but one of my carry J-Frames are .357s although I carry .38s in them for EDC (control issue). It is the other J-frame though that is the reason you should have included .38 Special in your list. My S&W 642 is the probably most carried CCW weapon in the United States. Regardless, it is the top selling CCW gun out there. and it is .38 Special only. Contrary to what has been said, I don't believe that the .38 is a little used, obsolete cartridge. I would say that the sales of .38 Special +P is right up there with the big boys! I know I live in an area where HCPs are very common and pretty much everybody with a HCP CCWs (not really neccessary in TN.) I would venture from talks with gun dealers in area that 75% carry 642s (they move out of shop as soon as they come in. In fact, most are ordered and never see display case!) and most of those are carried in pocket holsters.
A whole lot of people ( including myself) carry standard pressure .38 Specials in their 642s. Our Walmarts (main source of ammo in area) sell more .38 Special than any other pistol ammo by far.
 
#69 ·
Forum Newbie voted with his wallet today

I have a very nice Italian .45 Long Colt. Fun gun. Use it a lot. Not real good as a carry gun.
Neither is my Beretta 92. Nice "average" duty gun, I've had it since 1992.
Fun to blow through 16 rounds and do a reload and go again. Factory night sights.
A good nightstand gun. It would be easier to conceal a small anvil in your pants.

I finally did my CCW again 'cause AZ has gone to one-day training, renew every five years,
just paperwork & $'s. So, I wanted the very minimum size and weight that can "do the job".

Today, I picked up a S & W Centennial Airweight 642-2 NIB. It's next to me right now.
Good price. Why carry around the .357 capability/size when I will never go beyond .38 +P.
I'm not going hunting mule deer with this thing, after all. And, it is not my "range rat" gun.

It's a penetration issue with me. Why make a neat entry hole, and a pretty nice sized
exit hole as that hotshot .357 velocity goes "searching" for something or someone else ?

Per earlier comments, the various S & W .38 Special +P's fly out of the stores around here.
Sorta because a lot of salesmen around here point out the obvious stuff above for
"no-nothing" non-gunners trying to get something for the bedroom nightstand.

They didn't have to sell me. I believe it. I'm not proud. They work. Just enough.
 
#70 ·
.38 Special for me. It is accurate, has sufficient penetration, and comes in handguns I can actually carry everyday. No. it won't stop a charging bull elephant or an M-60 tank in one shot. But then again, I've grown old enough to know that I shouldn't irritate bull elephants and tanks!
 
#73 ·
I started with a 38 special (shot with a .357 revo) and I'm still thinking it'smaybe the best starting caliber.

I was advised by posters in this forum and the advise was darn good.

After about 15000 rounds fired under my belt I'm still using 38 sp's.

Accurate, not too noisy, little or no lead fouling, smaller gun wear, easy to load with moonclips, little felt recoil with an 'N' frame, cheap to reload....

I just ordered 10 000 more lead bullets.

After that I might think about caliber change, something like 45 ACP perhaps...
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top