In that list I'd go SA,but I have no personal experience with the rest.Kimber 9s of all sizes seem to have extraction issues lately and it seems some are due to too heavy a recoil spring,but I'd love to get my hands on one because extractors have been a long time problem and I'm thinking fitting one for a 9 screwed them up worse than than trying to get one right in a 45.Their warranty sucks too,a whole year for a grand.

Be sure to check the STI guns: STI INTERNATIONAL

STI is a Texas company that makes some awesome guns and has the best customer service in the industry.

I have the Spartan V in 9MM.

I purchased a Rock Island Armory 9mm Tactical model about 2-3 years ago. It's SA, it's my only 1911, has been highly reliable, and I do not regret the purchase. I use it at the range - don't carry it.

I decided on this pistol because of the tactical features/style, 9mm chambering, and price point -- it seems like it would be a good value and I would say it has been.

Dislikes... the front and rear sights were both black - no contrast, so I painted the front sight white and it's fine. The parkerized finish is a bit thin, but so far it wearing well. I replaced the grips with checkered walnut grips -- the original grips are smooth and plain but they are very comfortable. The grip change was more for cosmetic reasons.

All things considered, I'd say the dislikes are minor. I like the RIA.

From the ones you listed, I'd go with a SIG.

All the brands listed are good manufacturers... although my top pick would be the Sig as well... never met a Sig that I didn't like.

Those STI's are very nice, I've handled but never shot em'. Small shop that has a reputation for quality... and high price tags, but seem worth it if you have the funds.

I like the looks of Kimber, but I've yet to have a student bring one to a training class that didn't have multiple malfunctions. This fact will keep me away from purchasing one myself.

Went "window shopping" today for some 1911s. Taurus and Kimber are definitely out of the equation for me now, they just didn't feel good to me. No one had any Rock River or Rock Islands in stock. Did have a chance to handle the Springfield, Smith and Wesson and Sig. As well as a Para chambered in .45. I know I want a 9mm but the Para just felt sooo good, plus it was a heck of a deal I thought. I am really interested in the STI Spartan V and IV, but not one gun store near me has one. I like the Sig out of the ones I handled, but want to get my hands on an STI before I make a final decision.

I would have to go with a Springfield emp not a true 1911 but it was built for the 9mm. If it doesn't work they have the best customer service and will make it right quick. I don't know much about 1911's but when I decided to put my money on one it was an emp (40s&w) and I've been impressed (going to pick up the 9mm also as soon as my lgs can find one).

If it's in your budget the Sti Lawman 5.0 in 9mm is a real high end 1911 in 9mm. It's by far one of the best 1911's I have shot. the recoil is next to zero as its a full size 1911. I find myself shooting this one more than any other gun I own. Good luck on your search!

Any one familar with the Springfield Loaded 9mm. I love the looks of this gun. It is on the Calif. Dept. of Justice approved firearms list. It seems very few guns are approved for sale in calif.