I was at my local gun store to pick up my 1911 and I got to talking to my salesguy. I was thinking about buying the Desert Eagle and asked him to bring one out of the case. He handed me the DE and said he would be right back. He brought back a composite mag that looked like a toy accessory. then, he showed me the gun it belonged to. It was the 5.7. He explained the power and accuracy of this pistol. How is this gun even legal? Can anyone tell me their experience with this gun? Is it as good as I believe it would be? Screw the DE, 5 think I want one of these. I've always wanted to own a "SATAN KILLER."
After reading the after-action police reports of US policemen using the round (mostly out of a P90, once out of a FiveseveN), I think comparing it to a 22 magnum is greatly underestimating the 5.7 round. However, I do agree that the gun itself is large and uncomfortable. If they could squeeze that into a reliable medium-frame pistol, that'd be cool, but that's a pretty long cartridge. They might be able to stack them diagonally on top of one another (as in the DE .50 AE), and still leave you a decent number of rounds at your disposal. I'll have to sketch it out more (been planning on how to convert a future Glock to 5.7x29, for kicks).
Price is a huge deterrent though. The FiveseveN itself is usually between $800 and $1,000 USD, but the cost of ammo drives it up considerably higher.
Even were I armed with an FN P90, I'd have a different sidearm than a FiveseveN. Too unwieldy.
The price of the ammo isn't that bad. I have found it for 19.95 per box of 50.
It's one of my favorite guns and having 20 round mag is great and you get 3 with the gun. I love shooting it at a 100 yards at a Silhouette. I can't say I have a great group but I do hit the silhouette with all 20 rounds. I love the action on it and it's lightweight. The only thing I don't like is the front site, it's just to big and can make it hard to draw although I have the new blackhawk serp holster for it.
I get the ammo for $20 a box of 50 with a 2800 FPS. Show me a 22mag doing that out of a pistol.
If the Dems get into office they will go after it in a heart beat.
I've not personally chronographed the 5.7, but everything I have read shows about 2100fps (not 2800 fps) out of a pistol. Maybe it's 2800fps in the PS90, though.I get the ammo for $20 a box of 50 with a 2800 FPS. Show me a 22mag doing that out of a pistol.
Anyway, out of a pistol, 5.7 is pretty similar to .22 Magnum from a rifle (30gr at 2200fps, or 40gr at 1900 fps). I don't know anyone whose first choice in a defensive weapon would be a .22 Magnum rifle. Nice rabbit gun, though.
For those who came in late, the Democrats have already taken office in the House and the Senate.If the Dems get into office they will go after it in a heart beat.
I lump the FiveseveN in with the DE and the HK Mk. 23 - basically impractical guns that might be fun on the range but are not really suited to anything else.
I, for one, will contest that judgment because it conflicts with the popularity the gun is gaining in U.S. police forces. Lots of cops seem to like the reduced recoil (remember, the reason they went to .40 instead of 10mm), and greater accuracy, of the pistol.I lump the FiveseveN in with the DE and the HK Mk. 23 - basically impractical guns that might be fun on the range but are not really suited to anything else.
Not trying to argue, but personal feelings aside the FiveseveN, and its round, are gaining international popularity, and not without reason.
You sure couldn't tell it was a popular gun by the number of holsters sold for it. Without revealing actual sales figures, Galco holsters for Glocks and even 1911s (not a terribly popular cop gun) outsell FiveseveN holsters by at least 50,000%.I, for one, will contest that judgment because it conflicts with the popularity the gun is gaining in U.S. police forces. Lots of cops seem to like the reduced recoil (remember, the reason they went to .40 instead of 10mm), and greater accuracy, of the pistol.
Exactly which police departments issue the FiveseveN?
International popularity? Because the French and Belgians are such authorities on gunfighting?Not trying to argue, but personal feelings aside the FiveseveN, and its round, are gaining international popularity, and not without reason.
I've chronographed the 5.7 and get reading between 2650 to 2875. The average is less than my stated 2800 but who cares and why are you arguing everything people post?? I can slap a 33 rd mag into my G17 BIG DEAL. I just like having the 20 rounds of the 5.7 X 28. If that offends you so be it. I don't like the 22 mag round, I can't get a good group with it. That doesn't mean it doesn't work for others. When I mention the Dem I was thinking if they had the office of the president also.
By the way Thank you for your service and please be safe.
Last edited by spacedoggy; 06-03-2007 at 10:24 PM.
the usg pistol within 15 feet is capable of penatrating body armor even with the civ rounds
i have personaly shot fair groups at 200 yards and with the lack of recoil i would say it is a great gun
Last edited by clic2323; 06-03-2007 at 12:18 PM.
Now I remember why I like the 20 rounds. Because of the weight. It's a quater pound lighter than a Glock mag holding 20 rounds.
Does anyone know what the 5.7 round is classified as, rifle or pistol? I think it's a rifle round because of the neck.
Mike, I'll get back with some numbers (and locations) within the next couple days; restaurant's busy lately (meaning I'm tired more... shooting/training is so much easier than waiting...), so I can't promise being lightning quick about the response but it'll come.
Consider this a place mark.
Spacedoggy, I am sorry if my challenging things offends you. If everyone on the board agreed, I doubt it would be very interesting. There's always the ignore feature, though.
I think I gotta agree with Mike. Reviews I've read on the fiveseven show velocity around the 2000 fps range. And I've seen the comparison to the ballistics from a.22 mag rifle more than once. Seems to me that's a fair comparison. Even FN's published velocities show ~2000 fps for the 195 & 197.
I don't have anything against the fiveseven, I've even entertained thoughts about buying one. I bet it's a fun pistol to shoot. But for personal protection from a pistol, I'd rather have a 9MM, 357 sig, 38 super, 40, 10MM, ... etc.
Here's a link to Brassfetcher's website with some ballistic tests for the fiveseven & PS90. Every round from the fiveseven was sub 2000fps. It also looks like from his tests that the 5.7 suffers from lack of sufficient penetration and poor bullet integrity.
Ignore button now on.
I need to take a better look at my chronograph.
"To cut through body armor the .224-inch-diameter SS190 projectile incorporates a cone-shaped steel penetrator sitting atop an aluminum core surrounded by a steel jacket. Velocity of the 5.7x28mm SS190 ball load from a P90 PDW's 10.2-inch barrel is a respectable 2346 fps. Out of a Five-seveN pistol with 4.8-inch barrel it clocks 2133 fps. Despite the high muzzle velocity recoil is approximately 30 percent less than the 9x19mm. This 5.7x28mm load was specifically designed to defeat a NATO CRISAT target (consisting of a 1.6mm titanium plate with 20 Kevlar folds), and it will--even at 200 meters."
Good review on the firearm found at
Why even bother with the 5.7 when you can have PK2224? Launches a 53gr bullet at 2230 fps out of a converted Beretta 92. I still think that even that round is useless but it outperforms the 5.7 while chambered in a "common" converted pistol. You might find it interesting.